Velvety pumpkin pie in a crispy, flaky crust – this Phyllo dough pumpkin pie pastry is the ultimate fall dessert!

It’s time for fall baking! And the best way to turn a classic pumpkin pie into something unforgettable is to wrap it up in flaky Phyllo dough. The result is amazing!

Want more recipes like this? Sign up today to get them right in your inbox plus we’ll send you our FREE guide, Ready, Set, Eat! to learn our 3 simple secrets to help you meal plan like a pro!

Flaky Pumpkin Pastry

Pumpkin pie brings a sense of nostalgia for many of us. I blame it on its tasty mix of spices, causing scents like cinnamon and nutmeg to fill the air.

But what else can you make with pumpkin puree that isn’t pumpkin pie or muffins? Well, you can make a delicate pumpkin pastry with a flaky crust. It looks luxurious, but it’s actually super simple!

Let’s give ‘em PUMPKIN to talk about! This Pumpkin Pie Pastry is flaky, flavorful and so nostalgic of a classic pumpkin pie.

What You Need:

Here’s what you’ll need from the store. The exact amounts are in the printable recipe card at the bottom of this post.

Kitchen Tools:

Ingredients:

Phyllo Dough
Pumpkin Pie Filling
Sweetened Condensed Milk
Egg
Cinnamon
Chopped Pistachios
Butter
Powdered Sugar

Phyllo Dough Tips

Once you figure out how to work with Phyllo dough, it’s a lot easier! But the first time can be a little tricky. Here are some tips that will help you be successful the first time!

Thaw The Dough First

It’s important to thaw the filo dough according to its directions. Usually, this entails defrosting it in the fridge overnight or on your countertop at room temperature for 3-4 hours.

Be Gentle

Packaged filo dough is usually rolled, so unroll it gently to begin preparations. This part takes patience, so give yourself plenty of time.

Add Butter In Between Layers

Most recipes using filo dough will require at least 5 sheets. When you layer the sheets on top of each other, you’ll want some sort of liquid between each one: normally butter or olive oil. A pastry brush is key to make sure you get the liquid brushed on gently and evenly.

Keep The Dough Moist

As you layer and butter your filo dough, be sure to place a damp cloth on the unused filo dough to prevent it from drying.

How Do You Fix a Watery Pumpkin Pie?

Sometimes, pumpkin pie filling can get watery. This Pumpkin Pie Pastry avoids this problem, mainly because it uses a canned puree. Canned pumpkin puree is a lot less watered down than pureeing your own pumpkin.

Furthermore, the filling contains an egg, which helps stabilize its overall structure.

In general, to avoid a watery pumpkin pie, adding more eggs helps hold it together. A pumpkin pie’s filling is custard-like, so eggs are your best bet for maintaining the structure.

Pistachios Are Optional

If you don’t like the nuts in the filling, don’t add them! They are completely optional. It won’t change the texture or final result at all.

The Perfect Thanksgiving Dessert

I always turn to an easy pumpkin pie recipe during the holidays because I’m so busy preparing other dishes. So yes, I use pumpkin pie puree straight from a can – and I’m not ashamed about it!

So, should you use pumpkin pie filling or pure pumpkin puree? I used pumpkin pie filling. It you use pure pumpkin puree, you’ll have to add a little bit of brown sugar (about 2 tablespoons) and some pumpkin pie spice (about 1 tablespoon) to flavor it.

My Pumpkin Pastry is inspired by that easy pie filling. Instead of using it for a pie shell, it’s wrapped in a generous pile of filo dough, covered and baked in butter, then sprinkled with powdered sugar.

How To Store It

Store your baked pumpkin pastry in an airtight container in the refrigerator for about a day. It tastes best when it is fresh. If you keep it longer than a day, the Phyllo crust will soften.

Pumpkin pie pastry on a cutting board with a slice cut from one end.

No ratings yet